The Long(er) Term Effects of Promotions
Draft forthcoming
Abstract
This paper studies how internal promotions shape wages over subsequent employer-to-employer
(E2E) moves and unemployment-to-employer (U2E) transitions. Using panel data from the
National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1979 (NLSY79), I estimate event-study wage dynamics
around promotions and track post-promotion wage changes across labor-market transitions. I
find that promotions raise wages by about 17% on average and are followed by a sustained
acceleration in wage growth. Promotion-induced wage gains largely survive E2E moves, but are
selectively undone after unemployment: workers with a prior promotion experience an average
12% wage loss upon re-employment, while otherwise similar non-promoted workers exhibit no
average wage loss. Moreover, wage losses for promoted workers increase sharply with
unemployment duration (about 0.97 percentage points per month), compared with a much flatter
profile for non-promoted workers (about 0.43 percentage points per month). To interpret these
facts, I develop a model of promotions with asymmetric learning in which the incumbent firm
observes worker performance, while the outside market infers ability from coarse, publicly
observed career outcomes (promotion, retention, and unemployment duration). In simulations,
the model reproduces the differential wage responses to U2E transitions while still matching
the immediate impact of promotions on wages.